Laughter Is Sedition, Satire a Crime:
Thus Spoke the Keepers of Democracy
The Habitat—a beloved cultural and performance space in Mumbai—became ground zero in India’s ongoing war against free speech recently. Not for hosting a terrorist, not for planning a coup, but for doing something far more threatening to the fragile egos of today’s political bullies: allowing Kunal Kamra to tell jokes.
Yes, jokes.
Kunal Kamra, one of India’s most fearless satirists, recently recorded his stand-up special at The Habitat. Among the routines was a parody song that mocked Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde—yes, the same Eknath Shinde whose faction claims to represent the true Shiv Sena. The video, like most of Kamra’s work, was sharp, biting, and unapologetically critical of those in power. It didn’t take long for the Shinde camp to take offense.
And they did what cowardly political goons do when their egos get bruised—they ransacked the venue.
Gundagiri Disguised as Patriotism
Several men, allegedly belonging to the Shinde-led Shiv Sena, stormed The Habitat on April 1st. They vandalized the space, damaged property, and issued threats. Their message was loud and clear: dissent will not be tolerated. Criticism, even in the form of comedy, is a punishable offense if it targets the wrong people. Freedom of expression, in their eyes, is a privilege granted selectively.
And while Mumbai Police has since arrested some of the vandals, let’s not pretend this is justice. These attacks didn’t happen in a vacuum. They were encouraged—if not explicitly, then implicitly—by the toxic political climate cultivated by today’s leaders, where power is worshipped, and critique is criminal.
The Political Hypocrisy Is Stunning
The sheer hypocrisy of it all is mind-numbing. Politicians across India spew venom daily—from communal slurs to open threats. Ministers have made misogynistic, casteist, and inflammatory remarks on public stages with zero consequences. No FIRs. No police action. No “hurt sentiments.” No mobs smashing microphones or tearing up banners.
But when a comic strums a guitar and sings a parody? Suddenly, that’s intolerable. Suddenly, Maharashtra is under siege. Suddenly, the foot soldiers of Shinde Sena must rise in defense of their great leader’s honor.
Let’s be honest—this isn’t about hurt sentiments. It’s about crushing dissent. It’s about silencing independent voices who refuse to toe the line. It’s about telling the people of this country: you are free to speak, as long as you don’t speak against us.
Balasaheb Thackeray’s Legacy? Please.
And then there’s the laughable claim by the Shinde faction that they’re the true inheritors of Balasaheb Thackeray’s legacy. Really?
Say what you will about Balasaheb, but the man never hid behind mobs when someone criticized him. He stood his ground and faced the fire. He was a cartoonist, a satirist, and above all, someone who understood the power of words. He had the spine to engage with his critics—not cower behind goons.
Today’s Shiv Sena (Shinde edition) has none of that swagger. It’s reduced to a group of insecure strongmen who treat comedy like sedition and comedians like criminals. They are less successors to Balasaheb and more heirs to authoritarianism.
The Role of The Habitat: A Symbol of Cultural Resistance
The Habitat has been more than just a venue. It’s been a sanctuary for artists, poets, musicians, comics—anyone with something real to say. It’s one of the few remaining spaces in Mumbai where unfiltered, unapproved, and unapologetic art can exist.
That’s why it was attacked.
They weren’t just attacking a stage. They were attacking the idea that independent thought still has a place in India. They wanted to send a message—not just to Kamra, but to every artist, creator, and civilian who dares to challenge the status quo: stay in line, or else.
And Yet, the Silence Is Deafening
Where are the liberals who love to tweet from the safety of their echo chambers? Where are the Bollywood celebrities who champion freedom of expression during award seasons? Where is the outrage from comedians with millions of followers?
The truth is, India’s creative community has been browbeaten into silence. What happened to Kunal Kamra could happen to any of them—and they know it. So they stay quiet. Play safe. Water down their work. The result? A cultural landscape growing more bland, more sanitized, and more afraid.
This Is Bigger Than Comedy
Let’s not reduce this to just an attack on a comic or a venue. This is part of a much larger pattern of state-sponsored suppression. Universities are under surveillance. Journalists are jailed or killed. Students are branded anti-national. NGOs are strangled financially. Films are censored before they’re made. Books are banned before they’re read.
We are living through a moment where speaking truth to power is not just difficult—it’s dangerous.
And yet, the irony remains: politicians can say anything—and they face no consequences. They can label entire communities, rewrite history, stir violence, and gaslight millions with impunity. But if a civilian sings a parody or shares a meme, they’re branded seditious, disrespectful, or worse—”Urban Naxals.”
The Real Insult to India
The insult isn’t Kamra’s joke. The insult is a government so weak it fears a joke.
The insult is a party that rips up stages instead of facing questions.
The insult is a nation where politicians act like kings, and citizens are reduced to subjects expected to clap, nod, and shut up.
If this is what “New India” looks like, then it’s not new—it’s regressive. If this is what our democracy has become, then it’s not democracy—it’s a costume. A bad, ill-fitting disguise stretched over a thinly veiled autocracy.
In Conclusion: We Either Speak, or We Submit
Kunal Kamra’s stand-up special may or may not make you laugh. But this is not about comedy. This is about our right to speak, dissent, and challenge power. It’s about whether we allow bullies with power and political connections to dictate what can or cannot be said.
Because the truth is chilling: the longer we stay silent, the more we normalize this violence. The more we accept these attacks, the more we forfeit our own voices.
India doesn’t need comedians to be careful. It needs them to be brave. It needs its citizens to speak, question, ridicule, and protest. Because without that, we aren’t a democracy.
We’re just an audience—watching in silence, as the stage burns.
Thanks for reading, fr! Share if you like it enough. Follow us on Instagram & LinkedIn for more.
